The Victoire Ingabire verdict: No matter what the evidence, the haters will hate


Will our courts ever be seen to be free and fair (and impartial) in the eyes of bleeding heart ‘human rights campaigners and do-gooders’? I doubt that. It doesn’t matter whether the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda deems them so. It doesn’t matter whether the European Court of Justice deems them so. It doesn’t matter whether the Canadian Supreme Court deems them so. It doesn’t matter whether Rwandans, themselves, deem them so. No matter what happens, or what the evidence is, the narrative remains the same. ‘The courts are subjugated by the Government’.

Well, the Victoire Ingabire trial and judgment has put paid to that. If the courts were in the pockets of Village Urugwiro (as plenty of so-called experts think) they would have thrown Mrs. Ingabire into the prison and thrown away the key. After all, the public prosecutor asked the High Court to sentence her to life in prison.   Instead however, the Court sentenced her to eight years in jail on the charges of threatening state security and denying the Genocide.

If that isn’t evidence of impartiality I don’t know what is; especially when one realizes that the eight-year sentence is actually a six-year one because of time already served.  She’s been in prison since the 14th, October 2010. Throw in another, lesser-known fact, that a convict can apply for parole after serving a one-fourth of the sentence, and we have a situation where Ingabire can ask, for, and get, parole as early as tomorrow.  In fact, her co-accused Colonel Tharcisse Nditurende, Lieutenant Colonel Noel Habiyaremye, Lieutenant Jean Marie Vianney Karuta and Major Vital Uwumuremyi, will be free men tomorrow, despite their differing sentences ranging from two years and seven months to four years and six months.

According to the BBC, Ingabire’s supporters were “stunned by the verdict”. This is probably because they believed their own feverish rhetoric. In a press statement they released yesterday, they write, and I quote, that “sources confirm that a special cell in Mpanga central prison has been already prepared for her before this symbolical ruling by the High Court”. I’ve taken a bit of an interest in the ‘opposition’, and this is what I’ve gleamed. It seems to me that they live in a world where everything in Rwanda is bad and going to the dogs. They naturally assume the worst and they can’t begin to even fathom a situation where they are wrong in that assumption.

When they hear about a reshuffle in the military and intelligence services, they talk about a ‘coup plot’. When they learn about a programme to eradicate Nyakatsi (grass thatched huts), what they hear is a plot to condemn peasants to homelessness. When they hear about a VOLUNTARY vasectomy programme, they immediately assume that it is a Machiavellian plot to lower the birthrate. When Gacaca is instituted to try the hundreds of thousands of cases relating to the 1994 Genocide, these people assume that it was a plot to exact victor’s justice. In other words, nothing is good. Everything is bad. And if they had their way, society could collapse for all they cared. It would all be worth it just to see the back of this government. So, in my opinion, these people cannot be helped.

However, for the genuinely curious and open minded, I believe that this court case will help them distinguish the real from the fake. The facts on the ground prove that the government doesn’t always get its own way, and that, ladies and gentlemen, is proof that the courts aren’t merely institutions that rubber-stamp all and sundry.



2 thoughts on “The Victoire Ingabire verdict: No matter what the evidence, the haters will hate

  1. anneke verbraeken says:

    No matter the verdict, the haters hate Ingabire. Your New Times started a hate campaign the minute she set foot in Rwanda.Your president, your minister of foreign affairs, your local gouvernment minister, they all called Ingabire a ‘criminal’ while the trial was still going on. Trias Politica seems not your cup of tea.

  2. rwanyonga says:

    it is rather curious that you seem to forget or want everybody to forget ….”the elephant in the room”, hundreds of documents found by the Goverment of Neatherland in the Home of Ingabire in Holland ….. nobody want to talk about what is written in those documents, you rather distract people with empty rethoric , president said that, minister said that ……..well Obama , Bush any politician around the so called free world called Bin Laden a terrorist before he was convicted with a court….they regurarly order drones to kill people because of what they preach without giving them a chance to face justice ……

    i don’t know if you can read Kinyarwanda but Ingabire speeches are there for everybody to read , her link with FDRL are also there in the documents found in her own bedroom in Holland for everybody to see … but you don’t want people to see that because maybe you liked her plans maybe you wanted her to do what she wanted to do …..guess the consequences of her politics by experience don’t affect you, when things turn ugly we all know you take your children, dogs and pack your things and you are evacuated in the comfort of your Western world while we remain here and suffer …….guess what we know better now , it doesn’t matter of what you think or what your little NGO think….. we won’t gamble our own suvirval ever again ….and MOSTLY WE WILL NEVER ALLOW YOU TO DO SO you may as well start to get used to this new trend.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s